An offer for a business is fair when it is close to what other informed buyers would pay for the same business, on comparable terms, at the same time. The owner's number is not the test. The headline price is only part of it: how much is paid at completion, what conditions apply and how likely the deal is to complete all affect the value of an offer. A single offer on its own says little about market value.
What makes an offer for a business fair?
An offer is fair when it sits close to what other informed buyers would pay for the same business on comparable terms. Price, structure, conditions and certainty of completion together decide that, not the headline number alone.
The test is the market, not the owner's expectation. Valuers describe market value as the price a knowledgeable and willing buyer and a knowledgeable and willing seller would agree, with neither under pressure to transact. A valuation estimates that number. An offer is one buyer's version of it, and the two can differ in either direction for the reasons set out in How Much Is My Business Worth?
Beyond the headline, four things decide what an offer is worth.
- The basis of the price. Most offers state an enterprise value on a cash-free, debt-free basis with a normal level of working capital. Two offers with the same headline can produce different amounts once cash, debt and the working capital target are settled, which is covered in How Business Sales Get Paid.
- The consideration mix. Cash at completion, retentions, deferred payments, earnouts and equity rollover carry different levels of certainty. An offer with a large contingent component is worth less than its face value.
- The conditions. Finance approval, the scope of due diligence, landlord and customer consents and, for larger acquirers, ACCC approval all affect whether the deal completes and when.
- The exclusivity and timetable sought. A buyer asking for a long exclusive period is asking the seller to stop testing the market while it makes up its mind.
Taken together, these come down to price and probability. A higher offer with uncertain funding, broad conditions and a large earnout can be worth less than a lower offer that is mostly cash and likely to complete. A fair offer is one that holds up on both.
How do private equity firms work out what to offer?
A private equity firm works back from the return it needs. It estimates normalised earnings, applies a multiple it can justify on entry and exit, and tests the price against how much debt the business can carry and what the fund must earn over its holding period.
The starting point is the fund's own view of normalised EBITDA. The fund and its accountants rebuild the owner's figure, accepting some add-backs and rejecting others, and the price discussion starts from the fund's number rather than the owner's.
The fund then applies an entry multiple informed by comparable transactions and by what it expects to sell the business for at the end of its holding period, usually several years later. Funds generally avoid assuming they will sell at a higher multiple than they paid, so the price on entry is held back by what they expect the business to command on exit.
Funding comes from two sources: acquisition debt, sized on what lenders will advance against the business's earnings and cash flow, and equity from the fund. The more debt a business can support, the less equity the fund needs to commit for the same purchase, and the higher the price it can pay while still meeting its return. Businesses with stable, contracted earnings support more debt, which is one reason they attract higher prices from financial buyers.
The offer therefore sits close to the highest price at which the fund's model still reaches its target return, at a level of risk its investment committee will accept. Above that number the model does not work, whatever the merits of the business.
Two further factors move private equity pricing.
- Platform or bolt-on. A business bought as a platform is priced on its own earnings and growth prospects. A bolt-on to a business the fund already owns can justify a higher price, because its earnings join a larger group that the fund expects to sell at a higher multiple, and because costs can often be shared.
- Rollover and deferred amounts. Asking the owner to roll part of the proceeds into the new structure, or to take part of the price later, reduces the cash the fund commits at completion. A higher headline with significant rollover is a different offer from a lower headline paid in cash. How rollover works is covered in Trade Sale vs Private Equity vs Management Buyout.
Why do offers come in below an owner's expectation?
Most gaps come from the buyer's view of earnings and risk differing from the owner's. The rest usually come from the absence of competing bidders, or from the offer being made on a different basis from the number the owner had in mind.
Five causes account for most of the difference.
- A lower earnings base. Add-backs the owner regards as obvious, such as a family member's salary or a one-off legal cost, may not survive the buyer's review. Every rejected adjustment is multiplied by the multiple.
- Risk priced into the multiple. Customer concentration, dependence on the owner, a forecast the buyer cannot verify and key contracts with change-of-control clauses all reduce what a buyer will pay for each dollar of earnings. The factors that move the multiple are set out in How Much Is My Business Worth?
- No competition. A single buyer prices against the seller's alternatives, not against other bidders. Where the alternative is to keep running the business, the buyer has little reason to offer more than it needs to secure exclusivity.
- An anchor that was never the market. An owner's number often comes from a peer's sale in a different year, a valuation prepared for another purpose, or the amount needed to retire. None of these is evidence of what a buyer will pay now.
- A different basis. An enterprise value offer measured against an expectation of cash in hand will always look low, because debt, working capital adjustments and transaction costs sit between the two.
Some offers are also deliberately low. A first indicative offer from a buyer that expects to negotiate, or one testing whether the owner is under pressure to sell, may start below what that buyer would ultimately pay. The terms of the offer often show which kind it is.
What do the terms of an offer show about the buyer's view of risk?
The structure of an offer usually shows where the buyer is uncertain. Earnouts, deferred payments, broad conditions and long exclusivity each point to a specific risk the buyer wants the seller to carry, or wants more time to test.
Read this way, the terms are information. A buyer that pays most of the price in cash at completion, with limited conditions and a short exclusivity period, has largely formed its view. A buyer that asks for the opposite has not, or is passing risk back to the seller.
| Term in the offer | What it usually signals |
|---|---|
| Large share of the price in an earnout | Doubt about the forecast, or about whether earnings survive the handover |
| Significant deferred consideration | Funding limits, or caution about the transition period |
| Owner required to stay for an extended period | Dependence on the owner for relationships or operations |
| Finance condition | Funding not yet committed |
| Broad due diligence scope | Limited information so far, or areas the buyer already suspects |
| Long exclusivity period | A buyer wanting time to test the business, or to keep its options open |
| Specific indemnity raised early | A known issue the buyer has already identified |
| Equity rollover | Alignment with the owner, and less cash needed at completion |
Two points follow. First, an offer's terms and its price are connected: settling the risk a term reflects is often what allows a buyer to increase the cash paid at completion. Second, the same term can mean different things from different buyers. A finance condition from a fund with committed lending lines is close to a formality, while the same condition from a first-time acquirer is a material risk to completion. What each term is, and how it pays out, is set out in How Business Sales Get Paid.
What tends to move an offer higher?
Offers usually rise for two reasons: competition from other credible buyers, and evidence that reduces the risks the buyer has priced in. Timing and the trading performance of the business during the process also affect where the final price lands.
Competition is the most reliable of these. A buyer that knows others are bidding prices against them rather than against the seller's alternatives, and a process that brings several credible parties to the same point at the same time is designed to create exactly that. This is the gap between valuation and price.
Evidence works on the other side of the calculation. Where a buyer has discounted for a risk, information that settles the risk can recover part of the discount: a quality of earnings review that supports the add-backs, signed customer contracts in place of informal arrangements, a management team that holds the key relationships, or vendor due diligence that answers questions before they are asked. Preparation of this kind is covered in How to Prepare Your Business for Sale.
Trading matters throughout. A business that meets or beats its forecast while the process runs supports the price, and one that slips gives the buyer a reason to revisit it.
Some value is specific to one buyer. A trade buyer for whom the business fills a gap in territory, capability or customers may pay more than the earnings alone would justify, but that value usually only shows once that buyer is engaged and has done its own analysis.
Price and structure also trade against each other. Some sellers accept part of the price as deferred consideration or an earnout in exchange for a higher headline. Whether that improves the offer depends on how much of the increase is certain, which is the comparison worked through in How Business Sales Get Paid.
What do owners typically check before responding to an offer?
Before responding, owners usually establish who the buyer is and how the purchase is funded, and what the offer is worth once its basis, structure and conditions are taken into account. Many also test whether other buyers would be interested before engaging on price.
The usual questions are these.
- Who is the buyer, and can it complete? Its record in completing acquisitions, the source of its funds, and whether lender or investment committee approval is still needed.
- What is the price based on? Enterprise value or equity value, the treatment of cash and debt, and the working capital assumption. Without these, the headline cannot be compared with anything.
- How is it paid? The split between cash at completion, retentions, deferred amounts, earnout and rollover.
- What conditions apply? Due diligence scope, finance, third-party consents and regulatory approvals.
- What is asked in return? Exclusivity, its length, and the timetable to signing.
- What is expected of the owner afterwards? The transition period, any employment terms and the restraint of trade.
The answers usually shape the response an offer receives. Owners commonly involve their accountant and lawyer at this stage, because the after-tax proceeds and the effect of anything signed depend on the detail. Where the offer is the first approach the owner has received, whether to test the market first sits alongside all of these.
Where M&A Concierge fits
Judging an offer and creating the competition that improves it are both advisor skills, and they vary between firms. An advisor with strong buyer relationships in a sector can bring several credible bidders to the same point; one with deep transaction experience reads the terms of an offer for what they signal. An owner selling a business once rarely has a basis for telling which they are getting.
M&A Concierge works on M&A advisor selection: matching business owners with the right advisor for their business and their likely buyers, drawn from a proprietary M&A advisor database spanning 100+ industry sectors across the Australian mid-market. The firm an owner engages pays M&A Concierge a percentage of its retainer and success fees, and every firm pays the same percentage. What separates one advisor from another is covered in How to Find the Right M&A Advisor.
In a run process, buyers are generally asked to bid and no number is given, because a stated figure tends to become a ceiling. In direct negotiations owners are often asked for a number. Some give a range tied to a stated basis, such as enterprise value with a normal level of working capital, so that it is not compared with an offer made on a different footing.
Usually not in a competitive process, where indicative offers are revised before final bids are made. In a one-to-one negotiation the first offer often leaves room to move, but it also anchors the discussion that follows. The price can move in the other direction too, if due diligence turns up something the buyer did not expect.
Yes, in part. Owners commonly use an independent valuation as a reference point, an M&A advisor's read of current buyer appetite, and an accountant's calculation of after-tax proceeds. None of these settles what the market would pay. Only other buyers can show that, which is why a single offer is hard to judge on its own.
Not for a private sale. The "fair and reasonable" test comes from independent expert reports prepared under ASIC guidance for takeovers, schemes of arrangement and certain related party transactions, which mostly involve listed or widely held companies. A sale of a private business negotiated between its owner and a buyer has no equivalent test. Fairness there is a commercial judgement made against what the market would pay.
With no competing bid, the offer can only be judged against a valuation, the owner's alternatives and the terms on offer. The alternatives are usually to keep trading, to sell later, or to test the market now. Many owners treat a single unsolicited offer as a signal that buyers are interested, rather than as a measure of what they would pay.
General information only. This article describes how offers for businesses are commonly assessed in commercial terms. It is not financial, tax or legal advice, and it does not take account of any owner's circumstances.